Mary of the Miscarriage

Pray to Mary, she told me.

Your grandma did, when she had her miscarriages. She didn’t understand Mary, but she still turned to her.

It was the last phrase that stuck with me. Not the admonition to pray, not the reminder of solidarity, not even the memory of a relative I loved.

But the honest truth of another Catholic woman who didn’t automatically feel connected to Mary, who didn’t adore her with the thrill of May crownings and the comfort of rosary beads, who admitted that she didn’t always understand her but who still turned to her.

So I tried to make room in my heart. For her.

Whose motherhood likely looked nothing like she imagined, either.

Who learned, from the moment she found out, that love and loss go hand in hand.

Who stood in a long line of women who wrestled with their wombs – Sarah and Rebekah and Rachel and Elizabeth.

Who fled to the comfort of kindred spirits when the world proved too much.

Whose words were Fiat and Magnificat, the humility of hope and the awe of wonder.

Whose prayers spoke truth of a God who lifts up what is bent low.

Who heard awful words that a sword would pierce her own soul.

Who treasured all these things in her heart, even as it grew heavy.

Who might have wanted to carry again, too.

Who had to let her child go.


When I think of what this awful August has been, of all the people who have rallied round us, I see how half the women who held me close have known the pain of miscarriage themselves, who remember and reach out to say that it was a life, that it was a loss, that it will take time to grieve.

But the other half of the women who are helping to carry me never knew this heartache themselves. Yet they love me through it just the same.

Maybe I have to stop holding up similarity as the way to sympathy.

I’ll never be like Mary; she’ll never be like me. But if I stop at the contours of the immaculate conception and the boundaries of the virgin birth and the defenses of the dogmas we construct to keep holy the God-bearer, then I might count myself out of a kindred spirit before she ever has the chance to surprise me.

Maybe we do not need to mirror each other’s experiences to share the same story.

These days I don’t know where I stand, on the shifting sands of a loss so small the world cannot see it, a grief so heavy it drags down each step I take. But the one thing I know as the days keep arriving and leaving, as I ache to turn the page on this month with too much living and dying, is that I do not stand alone.

And all the women – who sent flowers and dropped off dinners, who wrote cards and keep writing emails, who pray me through and listen me through and cry me through and love me through –  maybe they are Mary to me.

Even if I do not understand, I keep turning.

Posted in


  1. Opal on 12 August 2021 at 6:19 pm

    The law of Mary

  2. Jenny on 18 September 2013 at 10:01 pm

    I ran across this a day after it appears my little one–my first–has stopped growing inside me. I found comfort in this beautiful piece of writing.

    • Laura on 19 September 2013 at 6:47 am

      Jenny, I am so sorry to hear of your loss. Please know that you and your baby are in my prayers.

  3. KJL on 27 August 2013 at 4:16 pm

    Your reflection here strikes a chord with me. When RG passed, I couldn’t compare myself to Mary–it smacked of a certain pride. But I could see that she, too, bore the worst pain in her heart, and yet turned to God in every moment of it. She relied, she trusted, she gave her fiat in each piercing of the sword. And that’s the part I worked to mimic while I was in the worst of my agony after he died. I still try to mimic it, every time I fear what is coming.

    Know too, the loss you feel is not “so small.” Perhaps the world can’t see it, but every soul that enters heaven, including the soul of your little one, is cause for great rejoicing. Up there, it is monumental. And the Lord knows–oh how he knows–the gravity of pain it means for you. It is in THAT dissonance, in YOUR fiat–despite the wretched pain–where suffering becomes akin to Christ’s. In your fiat, you unite with Jesus and His cross. And He knows how hard that is. But that’s why suffering for us is so redemptive.

    I continue to pray for you and your family. I hate that you are going through this.

    • Laura on 29 August 2013 at 2:00 pm

      Beautiful words, KJL, and even more beautiful faith. Thank you for continuing to reach out. Your empathy means so much to me. You and your family are in my prayers, too.

  4. Michelle @ Endless Strength on 27 August 2013 at 3:44 pm

    Beautiful reflection. I continue to lift you up in prayer. the pain of my own loss (in March) has softened, but the sadness remains and catches me in moments I don’t expect. The Rosary has been a huge comfort to me and I often think about our Mother Mary, holding my precious Gregory in her arms and it comforts me.

    I love your words here and I am so glad to know someone else feels like sharing through her sorrow (sometimes I have wondered if I was too “out there” with my grief, but it helped me through. And reading what you have written here continues that help for me, so thank you.

    • Laura on 29 August 2013 at 1:59 pm

      Thank you so much, Michelle. I am grateful to know that the words struck a chord and that you, too, have found comfort in Mary after your own loss. Please know that you are in my prayers, too.

  5. Lydia on 27 August 2013 at 8:28 am

    So lovely. I didn’t know. Praying for you!

    • Laura on 29 August 2013 at 1:58 pm

      Thank you, Lydia – I am so grateful for your prayers.

  6. A. S. Ellis on 27 August 2013 at 7:28 am


    God bless you.

    • Laura on 29 August 2013 at 1:57 pm

      Thank you for your kind words, A.S.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.